Pizza restaurants

Main Street Pizza

4.7 120 reviews 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM 66 W Main St, Ripley, NY 14775, United States

Discover this place

Main Street Pizza, nestled in the heart of Ripley, NY, is rapidly gaining a reputation as a local culinary gem. Customers rave about its pizza and wings, highlighting flavors that remind many of the robust offerings from Buffalo. Joell Daugherty notes the reasonable prices and warm staff, emphasizing the restaurant's welcoming atmosphere. The menu features a delightful range of pizzas, including a standout pepperoni and sausage combination that has become a favorite for patrons like Lisa Pfeiffer. She insists her husband exclusively eats Main Street's pizza, a testament to its quality. The thin-crust options, complemented by a hearty sauce and generous toppings, have garnered praise from food enthusiasts, such as Steve C., who rated it a solid 7.5–8 out of 10. Beyond pizza, Main Street Pizza also satisfies cravings with crispy wings, flavored to perfection as mentioned by Nathan Hufford, who appreciated the option for extra crispiness. The addition of baskets featuring chicken fingers and fish & fries widens its appeal to families. With its reliable delivery service and attentive staff, Main Street Pizza offers not just a meal, but a comforting experience that resonates well with the community. It's clear that this establishment is a must-visit for anyone seeking quality pizza and a warm atmosphere in Ripley.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Main Street Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for Main Street Pizza

4.7

120 reviews

100%

13%

Review highlights

Based on 120 reviews

Reviews for Main Street Pizza consistently highlight its flavorful and well-prepared menu offerings, particularly the wings and various pizza options featuring thin crusts and hearty sauces. Customers appreciate the reasonable pricing and friendly, polite staff, both in-person and during delivery. The restaurant’s attention to detail, such as accommodating special requests like extra crispy wings and ensuring food arrives hot, is frequently noted. Frequent mentions of the pleasant, small-town atmosphere and reliable delivery service further enhance its appeal. While presentations occasionally show minor imperfections, overall, Main Street Pizza is regarded as a dependable, quality choice for both locals and visitors seeking satisfying pizza and wings in Ripley, NY.

Joell Daugherty

May 20, 2025

Some of the best pizza & wings I’ve had since moving here from Buffalo. Reasonably priced and the staff are all so nice. This place is a gem

Nathan Hufford

Apr 22, 2025

My wife and I ordered some wings, butter garlic, and Buffalo, as well as a tossed salad and a slice of peanut butter pie. They even did the wings extra crispy as we requested. They were typical wingdings and quite tasty. We will try their pizza the next time we are in town.

steve c

Apr 20, 2025

Great little pizza place in a beautiful town. Thin crust, hearty sauce, larger pepperoni - not char cup. A little bit of cheese separation, let it cool a bit. 7.5-8/10 . Unexpectedly good.

Lisa Pfeiffer

Apr 17, 2025

Number one! This pizza is the only pizza my husband will eat! Hands done the best! we always get pepperoni and sausage, we get wings and salad most the time as well! They deliver which is so nice!!! They're always polite in the phone, and the drivers are very polite always thanking us for the tip, and telling us to enjoy our day!!! I live in NE, and the food has NEVER been cold ever !!! we order once a week usually on Thursdays! Best pizza place around!!!!

Doug Plummer

Apr 15, 2025

Passing through and had a supreme pizza delivered. It was outstanding and the price was right. Would definitely recommend this place

Secondary Account

Apr 09, 2025

Got some Pizza and Wings delivered out to the loves Truckstop , Was very satisfied with the overall performance of the staff , price , and the quality of the food was phenomenal. I will certainly order here again if and when I'm up in this area. Good place

Katie Valentine

Mar 09, 2025

Absolutely delicious food! Friendly, cheerful and genuine service! Such an adorable, home-town feel. The woman at the front knew everyone who came in and they were clearly all regulars. If we lived nearby this would be a routine lunch/dinner spot. It was clean and quiet, open late and just all around wonderful. Thank you Main Street Pizza for a great meal and experience- I really needed that today.

Cassie Smith

Feb 13, 2025

I've been driving past this small place for awhile now, and finally decided to place an order. If you're looking for a vast menu with great options, give this place a try. And also, don't forget dessert. They serve decadent lemon cream cake & peanut butter pie. It is melt in your mouth goodness & at a great price too. This place doesn't disappoint. My family's new favorite take out spot!